Union Leader Logo

Site Search

 Events Calendar > All

Giuliani: Give tax breaks for health insurance

Share on Facebook

Reader comments

By HOLLY RAMER
The Associated Press

Republican Presidential hopeful Rudy Giuliani yesterday offered a consumer-oriented solution to the nation's health care woes that relies on giving individuals tax credits to purchase private insurance.

Critical to Giuliani's plan is a $15,000 tax deduction for families to buy private health insurance, instead of getting insurance through employers. Any leftover funds could be rolled over year-to-year for medical expenses.

Campaigning in this first primary state, Giuliani said his goal is to give individuals more control over their health care. The former New York mayor said as more people buy plans, insurers will drop their prices, making insurance affordable to those who lack it now.

"Government cannot take care of you. You've got to take care of yourself," he said. "As more of us do that, the cheaper it will become and the higher in quality it becomes."

Giuliani offered the broad outline of his plan but his campaign did not provide many specifics. Asked how much his plan would cost and how many of the people without insurance it would help, Giuliani said he won't have those answers for two or three months.

He also acknowledged that it could take years for insurers to drop their prices and make insurance affordable to those who don't have it.

Democratic candidates John Edwards and Barack Obama have proposed more detailed steps to deal with the 47 million Americans lacking health insurance. Edwards' plan has an individual mandate requiring all Americans to have coverage. Employers would have to share the cost of insuring workers or pay into a public program.

Edwards estimates that his plan would cost $90 billion to $120 billion per year and would be financed by repealing President Bush's tax cuts on those making more than $200,000 per year.

Obama's plan calls for the creation of a public program similar to the health plan offered to federal employees, and a National Health Insurance Exchange for consumers to shop among private plans. Employers would have to share the cost of insuring workers.

Obama estimates his plan would cost $50 billion to $65 billion per year, paid for by letting Bush's tax cuts expire on those making more than $250,000 per year.

Giuliani used his appearance to continue criticizing the Democratic candidates, contending that their plans amount to socialized medicine.

"We've got to solve our health care problem with American principles, not the principles of socialism," he said. "I know Democrats will say this is unfair, I know they'll squeal... But I'm a realist. I face reality, which is: if you take more people and have government cover it, it's called socialized medicine."

He argued that Edwards' plan would cost twice what the Democratic candidate estimated.

Giuliani also spoke in favor of tort reform, saying those who are legitimately injured by doctors should be compensated, but damages should be capped and those who file frivolous lawsuits should have to pay the physician's legal fees.

"If a person gets injured, he should be compensated, but he shouldn't get the brass ring or win the lottery," Giuliani said.

The New Yorker leads in several national polls, but trails Republican rival Mitt Romney by double digits in a recent New Hampshire survey.

Answering questions yesterday afternoon at a hospital in Norwalk, Conn., Giuliani acknowledged that the U.S. health care system has flaws but said it is still the best in the world and would benefit from a market-based solution to the insurance issue.

In response, Democratic National Committee spokeswoman Karen Finney said, "the Giuliani-Bush health care plan has already been rejected by the American people as a risky scheme."

YOUR COMMENTS


Giuliani's health care plan would bankrupt the American government. His plan eliminates income taxes for approximately 1/3 of all Americans. Giuliani does not say where he would obtain the lost revenue. His plan is unrealistic. It simply does not make sense. What government programs would he eliminate? The value of the dollar would decrease significantly if the American government went into debt to such a greater degree due to the sale of government bonds. Foreign nations already have a problem purchasing American bonds due to the government deficit. Foreign nations would not purchase American bonds. Current holders of American debt would see the value of their investments decrease due to the increase in the supply of bonds and the increased government deficit. His plan is irresponsible and foolish.

In contrast, Obama's plan would cover all Americans in need of health care insurance and would not raise taxes. The plan is funded by regulations designed to increase competition in the insurance industry as well as by the creation of an exchange the purpose of which is to provide a coordinated marketplace for individuals to purchase insurance at significantly lower rates due to increased competition in a single marketplace for the uninsured. Obama's plan is realistic and makes sense.
- Scott Romanov, E. Brunswick

NOTE: If you have visited this page before, newer comments may be hidden. Press F5, or hold down the Ctrl key while reloading or refreshing the page. (Another option for Firefox users is the Clear Cache add-on.)